4 Reasons Why a Personal Injury Lawyer Will Not Take Your Case

Written by Greg on April 21, 2017

People wonder why attorneys will not accept their case and this article is written to give a brief overview of the issue. After someone has been injured they may believe they have a case but cannot find an attorney who will accept their case. In order to help you understand why, we list below some of the things that may be helpful for your consideration.

  1. How the Accident Occurred

One of the earliest considerations by the best personal injury lawyers is how the accident actually happened. In order to hold someone financially accountable, that person  had to breach a legal duty or in layman’s terms “do something wrong” that caused the injury.

It is not enough that the injury happened on a premises or that the injuries are severe. One of the tests for someone wanting to make a claim in Texas is to ask yourself “what did they do wrong”?  

An example would be that in a car accident were you were supposed to yield the right-of-way but the other driver impacted your vehicle. Perhaps both parties are at fault. In our example, it could be the other driver was speeding. Who was at fault for an accident is a question that the judge or jury must answer in Texas. But an experienced personal injury attorney will make a quick assessment on liability in deciding to take on a case or not. The more experienced the lawyer, the better they get at initial case evaluation.

In order to have a viable personal injury claim in Texas, the injured person must be able to prove that the other party was at fault and that their fault was less than 51%. If you may have been partly at fault, an attorney may decline your case because he thinks the monetary award will be reduced or eliminated depending on the extent of your fault.

Governmental immunity in Texas is another reason why attorneys may not accept personal injury claims against school districts or governmental entities. If you want to pursue a claim against a public school, good luck finding a lawyer in Texas.

In short, a personal injury attorney will analyze whether they feel legal responsibility can be established and gauge the likelihood of success. If the lawyer does not feel good about the chances of success the odds of the lawyer taking the case on contingency fee are slim.

  1. The Injury is Not Serious Enough

Attorneys hear all the time “I could have been killed“, that is not an element of legal damages submitted to the jury in Texas.

Another saying that is a red flag to an attorney is “it’s a matter of principle“. Generally, that type of claim does not put any butter on the bread for the lawyer.

Personal injury lawyers are looking for damages as a gauge of the expected recovery for handling a case. Speculative damages whether financial or injury do not really help you obtain an attorney. One method of looking at the seriousness of the claim is the medical treatment you have sought and expect to get in the future. If the accident happened several months ago and you have not sought any treatment, many lawyers will decline the case.

In personal injury cases, how bad you are hurt is the most important factor in a case. If your injuries are minor, an attorney may pass on your case because the expected monetary compensation will likewise be minimal compared to the time and out of pocket expenses they estimate.

Additionally, the cost of developing the testimony to prove up your injuries has to be factored into the analysis of the attorney. If the cost of the expected depositions exceeds the expected return on the case, an attorney most likely will not accept the case.

  1. You Sound Like You Have Talked to Many Other Lawyers

We believe it is extremely important for personal injury victims to select the right attorney for their case. This includes making sure that the attorney has expertise in the subject area of the accident and that they are a good personal fit. If you were hit by a semi truck you would want to find the best truck accident attorneys near you. And if your case involved other specialized areas you should consult an attorney with expertise in the area.

Nevertheless, many cases are turned down because the potential client appears to be looking to select the attorney based upon the feedback they receive on the value of the case.

It is almost impossible for an attorney to give a client an accurate value of the case before the attorney knows all of the facts including the insurance coverage available by the defendant. Victims should be wary of attorneys placing a value on a claim after the first consultation.

Further, if you have been “released” or “dropped” from another law firm the attorney will think twice about the case from either a liability perspective, insurance perspective or an unreasonable expectation perspective. If the law firm you chose initially investigates the facts and decides it is not in their interests to work the case, finding a new lawyer will be harder than the first.

  1. The Economic Reality of Pursuing the Case

Personal injury attorneys take cases on a contingency fee basis. This requires the lawyer to make a business judgment on each case they agree to handle.

Factored into that business judgment is such things as, the amount of time that the attorney expects to spend on the case, the cost out of pocket for the attorney to develop the case, and the expected fee.

The attorney must consider whether the time effort and money are “worth it” for the attorney to handle. The more experienced and successful the attorney the higher that number becomes.

To put this in perspective, defense attorneys are paid by an hourly rate for each minute they spend on a matter. The client also must pay upfront all of the case expenses and the defense attorney gets paid whether they win or lose the case.

Another situation that proves difficult is when the personal injury victim has substantial injuries and also huge hospital obligations for the treatment. This can come into play when the available insurance to cover the damages is insufficient and the hospital would receive the first money out of a case.

In short, attorneys who handle contingency fee personal injury cases must be business people and accept or decline cases after considering how much time and money they must expend to move the case forward balanced against the fee that they expect to receive should they be successful and the risks in the case. The more successful the lawyer the harder the screening process is for taking new cases.

Call Baumgartner Law Firm for a no-obligation consultation on a Houston injury claim-  (281) 587-1111!

Posted Under: Practice of Law

Giving Back to The Community

We are committed to supporting our community
Baumgartner Scholarship
See All Practice Areas Meet Attorney Greg Baumgartner See Previous Case Results Read Client Reviews & Testimonials Read Our Blog Contact Us