Houston Distracted Driving Accident Lawyer: How to Prove Driver Inattention

Houston distracted driving accident lawyer Greg Baumgartner

After a crash, the other driver may say, “I just did not see you.” That does not answer why. Was the driver reading a text, looking at a navigation screen, reaching for something, or simply not paying attention?

Greg Baumgartner’s first concern in a suspected distracted-driving case is proof. A phone in the car is not enough. We need evidence showing what the driver was doing, when it happened, and how it contributed to the collision. Greg is a Houston car accident lawyer who has handled serious injury claims for more than 40 years.

What counts as distracted driving?

Texting is only one form of distraction. A driver may be looking at a map, selecting music, watching a screen, talking with passengers, eating, or reaching for an object. Some tasks take the driver’s eyes off the road; others take hands off the wheel or attention away from driving.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s distracted-driving guide explains the different ways attention can shift from the road.

How do we prove that distraction caused the crash?

Start with the driver’s conduct

A witness may have seen the driver looking down. Dashcam footage may show no braking before impact. The driver may have made a statement at the scene or given an account that changes later. Those details can point investigators toward the right records.

Find electronic evidence lawfully

Depending on the facts and what is legally available, phone records, app activity, messages, vehicle systems, and electronic discovery may help establish a timeline. Records do not always reveal exactly what was on a screen, and obtaining private material can require tailored discovery or legal process. It is important not to promise that every text or app action can be recovered.

Compare the timeline with physical evidence

Vehicle damage, braking evidence, road conditions, video, and witness accounts help answer the next question: did the distraction make a difference? A phone record alone does not prove that phone use caused a wreck.

For a collision caused by someone drifting into opposing traffic, our head-on crash investigation guide explains the separate evidence issues. If the crash occurred at a traffic signal, see the discussion of disputed intersection crashes.

Why fast preservation matters

Nearby video can be overwritten. Vehicles may be repaired. Witnesses may become hard to locate. The driver’s explanation may also be clearer when recorded near the time of the wreck.

Greg’s advice is to save your own records first: photos, dashcam files, the crash report number, names of witnesses, and any messages from the other driver. Do not try to access someone else’s device or accounts. Proper legal requests are the way to seek evidence held by another person or business.

How do we get the other driver’s phone records?

Phone evidence is rarely handed over voluntarily. We start with a preservation letter to the driver and the insurance company asking that the phone and its data be kept intact. Once a lawsuit is filed, records can be requested from the driver and subpoenaed from the wireless carrier.

Carrier records usually show the time of calls, texts, and data activity. They do not show the content of messages, and they do not show everything a driver was doing on the screen. Answering that can require a forensic examination of the phone itself, and a court decides whether to allow one.

Carriers keep some records for a limited time, which is one reason delay hurts these cases. We compare the phone timestamps with the 911 call, vehicle data, and any video to see whether the phone use lines up with the moment of the crash.

Distracted Driving Accident in Houston

What does Texas law say about phones and safe driving?

Texas prohibits reading, writing, or sending an electronic message on a handheld phone while driving, unless the vehicle is stopped (Transportation Code Section 545.4251). The law took effect on September 1, 2017. A first offense carries a fine of up to $99, and a repeat offense up to $200. The statute provides defenses for hands-free use, navigation, reporting an emergency, and playing music. Separate rules restrict phone use by drivers under 18 (Section 545.424) and in school crossing zones (Section 545.425).

A ticket is not required for an injury claim. The civil question is whether the driver used reasonable care. A driver who was looking at a map, changing music, or eating can be negligent even though none of those acts violates the texting law. When a driver did violate the statute, the violation can be strong evidence of negligence.

When a distracted-driving crash causes serious injuries

Some collisions cause more than a short period of soreness. Brain injuries, spinal injuries, fractures, and time away from work may require medical records, specialist opinions, and evidence of future needs. Our Houston brain injury practice addresses one of the injuries that may follow a severe impact.

We do not assign a dollar value just because a driver was using a phone. Liability, medical evidence, insurance coverage, and long-term effects all matter.

Why Greg focuses on the evidence before the accusation

Baumgartner Law Firm has handled serious injury claims since 1985. Greg stays personally involved in the cases the firm accepts. We would rather show an insurer the proof of distraction than rely on an angry accusation the evidence cannot support.

For the broader process of pursuing an injury claim, see our Houston car accident lawyer page. If you suspect a distracted driver caused your injuries, call (281) 587-1111 for a free case review. No attorney fee is owed unless we recover money.

Houston distracted driving accident lawyer
Distracted driving accident statistics

Frequently asked questions

Can I prove texting without seeing the other driver’s phone?

Sometimes. Video, witnesses, admissions, and records obtained through proper legal processes may help. The available proof differs in every case.

Does a police report prove the driver was distracted?

Not necessarily. A report may identify suspected distraction, but the conclusion should be checked against the underlying evidence.

What if the driver was using GPS?

Navigation use does not automatically establish negligence. The question is whether the driver failed to use reasonable care and whether that failure contributed to the crash.

Auto Accident Resources

Learn more from our Houston car accident lawyer about the types of crashes we handle and what to do after a car wreck.

Types of Car Accident Claims

After a Car Accident

 

For a FREE Consultation Contact Us Today

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Your Name*

Related Links

Our Experienced Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help!

For a Free Consultation with a Preeminent Rated Injury Lawyer

Case Results

Injured by a Distracted Driver in Houston, Call Baumgartner Law Firm for Help!

For Your Free Consultation- Call (281) 587-1111

Baumgartner Law Firm

6711 Cypress Creek Pkwy, Houston, TX, 77069

(281) 587-1111

testimonials
Client Reviews
Mayra T
Houston Personal Injury Victim
Mr. Greg is a great personal injury lawyer. Looking for the best help? Call Baumgartner Law Firm!
Brian Wilson
Houston Personal Injury Victim
I highly recommend this law office. Greg Baumgartner is knowledgeable, dependable, honest and truly has the client’s best interests at heart.
Callie M
Houston Personal Injury Victim
Greg, a personal Injury Lawyer at Baumgartner Law Firm represented me in my personal injury case. I am very happy with the case result. Baumgartner is a GREAT law firm with GREAT people. They get RESULTS.
Cindy S
Houston Personal Injury Victim
My experience with Baumgartner law firm was excellent. They took the time to hear my concerns and kept me informed throughout the process. They fought for the best resolution for my case. Working with Greg and Lissa gave me peace of mind in a scary and stressful situation. I highly recommend their services.
Request a Free Injury Case Review

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Your Name*

Let Our Experienced Injury Lawyer Assist You