Skip to Main Content


What Happens When You Reject an Insurance Settlement Offer?

Home » Blog » What Happens When You Reject an Insurance Settlement Offer?
What happens when you reject a settlement offer?

Dealing with insurance companies after an accident can be overwhelming. Often, the first settlement offer from an insurance company might not fully cover your damages or losses. Rejecting this offer can lead to better compensation. Here’s a detailed look at what happens when you reject an insurance settlement offer and the steps to ensure you get what you deserve.

Understanding the Initial Offer

Insurance companies aim to minimize their payouts to maximize profits. The first offer you receive is likely to be lower than what your claim is worth. Recognizing this can help you prepare for negotiations.

Read More: Tips For Dealing with Geico on an Injury Claim

Reasons to Reject a Settlement Offer

Inadequate Compensation

The initial offer might not cover all your expenses, like medical bills, lost wages, property damage, and pain and suffering.

Future Expenses

Some injuries require long-term treatment or result in permanent disabilities. An initial offer might not cover these future medical expenses.

Non-Economic or Human Damages

 Insurance companies often undervalue non-economic damages, such as emotional distress and loss of enjoyment of life. These should be compensated fairly.

Steps to Take After Rejecting a Settlement Offer

Gather and Present Evidence

Strengthen your claim with substantial evidence. Collect all relevant documents, including medical records and repair bills. Consider obtaining expert testimonies or independent medical examinations to support your case.

Communicate Clearly

When rejecting a settlement offer, clearly and professionally explain why the offer is inadequate. Provide detailed reasons and present your evidence to support your position. A well-documented response can help in negotiations.

Make a Counteroffer

After rejecting the initial offer, present a counteroffer that reflects a fair settlement. This counteroffer should be based on your total damages and supported by your evidence. Be prepared for multiple negotiations, as insurance companies rarely accept the first counteroffer.

Consider Legal Assistance

Engaging an experienced personal injury attorney in Houston can significantly improve your negotiating position. An attorney can provide valuable insights, handle communications with the insurance company, and advocate on your behalf.

The Role of a Demand Letter

A demand letter is crucial in the negotiation process. It outlines your claim, the extent of your damages, and the compensation you seek. A well-crafted demand letter includes:

Detailed Account of the Incident

Describe how the accident occurred, who is at fault and why, including dates, locations, and involved parties.

Injuries and Medical Care and Expenses

Summarize your injuries, medical treatment, and any ongoing or future medical needs.

Financial Impact

Detail all financial losses, including medical bills, lost wages, and property damage, with supporting evidence.

Non-Economic Damages

Describe the emotional and psychological impact of the accident and how it has affected your life.

Read More: State Farm Claims and Car Accidents

Preparing for Possible Outcomes

Continued Negotiations

Negotiations may continue for some time, with offers and counteroffers exchanged. Patience and persistence are essential. Document all communication and keep records of interactions with the insurance company.


If negotiations stall, mediation may be next. Mediation involves an agreed upon neutral third party to facilitate a fair agreement. Mediation is informal and aims at mutual agreement.


If all else fails, pursuing a lawsuit may be necessary. Litigation is formal and time-consuming but can lead to fair compensation. Your attorney will guide you through the process, from filing the lawsuit to representing you in court.

Contact the Personal Injury Attorneys at Baumgartner Law Firm for Help

Call us for a FREE CONSULTATION about your case. We will listen to your story and offer candid analysis.

Baumgartner Law Firm

6711 Cypress Creek Pkwy, Houston, TX, 77069

(281) 587-1111