How A Personal Injury Lawyer Evaluates An Injury Claim

Written by Greg on May 18, 2015

How you evaluate a personal injury claim depends in part upon the seat at the table you occupy. Personal injury attorneys evaluate claims based upon their experience and perceptions, insurance companies evaluate claims from somewhat different perspective and some insurers actually rely upon computer models such as colossus.

Deciding whether or not to accept a personal injury case there are some components of that are important for us to determine whether the case is one that fits our practice model and we can accept.

The first step in the evaluation process is to speak with the personal injury victim or their family and get a detailed description of what happened. Plaintiff’s attorneys must evaluate the potential clients to see if they are compatible and a good fit for the law firm. An injury claim can be a lengthy process, particularly in the when litigation is necessary and its best that everyone bonds.


  1. Who is at Fault

The first major hurdle in evaluation of any personal injury claim is legal responsibility.

Someone must have done something or failed to do something they were legally required to do that caused the accident or the plaintiff’s injuries in order to meet the legal responsibility hurdle. In a truck and 18-wheeler accident fault can partly be determined by violations of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations. For a dram shop or case against a bar or club, fault my be determined by how may drinks the intoxicated driver was served. In a car crash it could be the other driver failing to yield the right ow way.

A good question to ask: What have they done wrong to cause the accident or injure me? 


2. What are my Damages

Assuming the matter gets by the legal responsibility analysis, the next step is legal damages. This requires an assessment of what legal damages are available to the victim. You can have an auto accident caused by someone falling down drunk but you walk away from the crash unharmed and other than the property damage claim there would be no other legal damages. You can not collect damages on what might have occurred.

Alternatively you can have very severe damages and have no defendant with legal responsibility. The personal injury attorney must carefully evaluate the damages of the claimant in deciding whether to accept the case or not. Some law firms like ours are committed to handling a few very serious injury claims and others are more of a volume practice. Also, very bad damages alone do not usually convince an attorney to take the case. Without fault, or insurance coverage, justice will be very hard to achieve.


3. Insurance Coverage

Finally, the lawyer must also consider the insurance coverage available to pay legal damages as part of the analysis on whether or not to take a case.

There’s an old saying “you can’t get blood from a turnip” and that applies to lawsuits and particularly those in Texas.

Our law firm does not generally handle cases where insurance coverage is not available to cover the claim. It is one thing for attorneys to bet their time and their money on winning a case and another to bet on whether or not they can collect after they win. In Texas, it is particularly difficult to collect from those outside of an insurance policy.

There are some torts that are excluded from most insurance policies and a good example would be an intentional tort such as an assault. Other times, there are situations where liability is clear, damages are great but there is no way for the victim to get paid for the damages (i.e. no insurance).

Not all cases require an attorney. Generally, the more serious the injury the more likely you will need an experienced personal injury attorney to handle the case. Frequently, victims call our office after attempting to handle a case on their own only to find out that they are over their heads.

Unfortunately, in many cases they have done something that hurt the value of the case or failed to do something they needed to do in order to help prove the case.

When the victim hears from the insurance company that they are “accepting liability”, that does not mean that they are going to be fair when it comes to talking about money.

Here are some tips about negotiation of a personal injury claim.


4. Talk to an Experienced Lawyer

Personal injury victims considering handling the case on their own would be well advised to take advantage of a free consultation from a personal injury attorney and do online research to learn about the process.



Brought to you by:

Baumgartner Law Firm

6711 Cypress Creek Pkwy

Phone: 281-587-1111

Posted Under: Consumer Information

Giving Back to The Community

We are committed to supporting our community
Baumgartner Scholarship
See All Practice Areas Meet Attorney Greg Baumgartner See Previous Case Results Read Client Reviews & Testimonials Read Our Blog Contact Us